top of page

6-Inch vs. 5-Inch Gutters: Which is Right for You?

Your gutters are the most critical part of your home’s water protection system. According to the latest statistics, one in 50 homeowners will make an insurance claim for water damage this year.

Upgrading your guttering system is vital for protecting your home, but have you considered which size guttering works best? You have two choices: 6-inch gutters and 5 in. gutters.

Here’s what you need to know about these two gutter systems and how to determine the right choice for you.


6-Inch vs. 5-Inch Gutters: What’s the Difference?

Guttering systems require you to answer essential questions like “What size downspout for a 6-inch gutter?” and “What material works best for me?”

It underlines the importance of consulting a professional on style and functionality before settling on a guttering system. Let’s analyze the differences between the two.

6-Inch Gutters: Pros and Cons

First, 6” gutters will be recommended by most professionals. A 6-inch seamless guttering system can carry up to 50% more water than a 5-inch gutter. With water damage being the third most common cause of homeowner loss, the added capacity can save your home from damage during periods of heavy rain.

Pros

  • Water Capacity – These larger gutters hold 50% more water than other guttering systems.

  • Better Protection – Your fascia board mitigates your home’s exposure to the weather. These gutters cover the whole fascia board without leaving any gaps.

  • More Robust Appearance – Many homeowners prefer these gutters because they have a more robust appearance. Regarding curb appeal, 6-inch gutters offer an impression of structural soundness.

  • Easier Maintenance – These gutters have an extra-wide mouth, making it easier to slide your hand in and remove debris.

Cons

  • More Expensive – There is a price difference between 5 and 6-inch gutters. Expect to pay more for these guttering systems.

  • Unsupported – Some fascia boards may not support a 6-inch guttering system, meaning you’ll need to do more renovation work to install them. Thankfully, this isn’t a problem with most homes.

  • Unappealing Aesthetic – Some homeowners prefer the oversized look, but it’s always a matter of opinion. These oversized gutters could compromise the aesthetic of your home, especially if it’s an older one.


5-Inch Gutters: Pros and Cons

In the debate over 5” vs. 6” gutters, the most common type of gutter is the five-inch. These are the most affordable gutters and are what most people think of when they imagine a guttering system.

Despite having less water capacity, five-inch gutters are suitable for most homes. Here's what you need to know when weighing up 5 vs. 6-inch gutters.

Pros

  • Fit on Any Home – Five-inch guttering systems are the standard size. Regardless of your home, it will have no problems supporting these guttering systems.

  • More Affordable – If cost is your primary concern, five-inch guttering is the budget option. Their oversized cousins will command higher prices.

  • Concealed Gutters – Due to their smaller size, five-inch guttering is suitable for concealed hangers that hide their presence. If this is your desired look, five-inch gutters are the only way forward.

Cons

  • Less Water Capacity – Live in a part of the country more prone to torrential downpours, and standard guttering sizes are likely to lead to overflow.

  • More Blockages – Due to their smaller capacity, storm season can quickly lead to leaves and other debris building up faster.

  • Lack of Protection – Standard gutters leave a small gap between the gutters and the fascia board, potentially leaving your home vulnerable.


How to Choose Between 6-Inch vs. 5-Inch Gutters

Should you opt for 6-inch gutters vs. 5-inch, or is it the other way around?

Firstly, never make this decision without calling a professional to inspect your roof and make recommendations.

Several considerations govern which gutters serve your home best, including roof size, style, pitch, local weather conditions, and aesthetic preferences. An expert will perform a visual inspection and discuss any concerns you have.

For example, if you live out in the middle of the Arizona Desert, rain likely isn’t a significant threat to your home. On the other hand, Florida residents must contend with multiple tropical storms and hurricanes annually. In this environment, an oversized gutter will be helpful.

Regardless of your decision, working with the right professional is pivotal to making the best decision and protecting your home from harm.

So, what do you need to know about choosing oversized guttering systems?

  • Cleaning – No guttering system that exists today is self-cleaning. Larger gutters will move debris away from your home, but the build-up is inevitable sooner or later.

  • Capacity vs. Flow – Remember, a high-quality guttering system isn’t just how much your gutters can hold but how quickly they can move water away from your home.

  • One Size Fits All – The issue of one size fitting all is false. At Gutt-R-Done, we are experts in analyzing your home's size, pitch, and local weather conditions. Our seamless guttering systems are perfected for your home, not somebody else’s.

With all this in mind, you’re equipped to decide which system is best for your home. Work with a guttering professional and protect your home from water damage today.


Transform Your Home’s Guttering System with Gutt-R-Done


Deciding between 6-inch vs. 5-inch gutters is far from straightforward. No matter your decision, choosing a seamless guttering system offers countless benefits compared to traditional gutters.

If you’re searching for a company that specializes in gutters in Lafayette, LA, Gutt-R-Done is the best option. We specialize in installing gold-standard seamless guttering systems to suit your home. We understand budget is a concern, so we offer tailored plans and packages to match your expectations.

Transform your home’s guttering system and give your residence the best protection. Schedule your free consultation by calling orcontacting us online today.

17 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All
bottom of page